
Up-to-date this is the best lesbian interest film that I have ever watched as tells a story that is so REAL but the way is told makes even more real and I know that many that have ever lived a one-night-stand at a hotel room will easily understand why I say this film story resembles real-life. But more amazing is the way is told and seems that Julio Medem had excellent source(s) of information about what happens beyond the close doors when two women meet and fall in love. Still even more amazing is the fact that this film is inspired by Matias Bize’s En la Cama, a Chilean film that tells a similar story but the protagonists are a man and a woman. How a filmmaker can portrait so good real-life about something I’m sure has never seen much less lived? Interesting.
The films tells about two strangers, one Russian and one Spaniard, that meet on their last night in Rome, feel attracted to each other, end-up in Alba’s room and slowly -very-slowly- start to open themselves to each other until they tell truth, get scared for what they’re feeling and it’s too late as feelings have overcome whatever they have to face in their real-lives they tried so hard to protect. Very simple story told with many conversations, some sex but more love, some silences, many sights and many facial expressions. Fantastic!!!
I’m totally biased but I enjoyed more Elena Anaya’s Alba than Natasha Yarovenko’s Natasha, after all Anaya is a more accomplished actress and her performance here is just perfect for the role she’s playing, but Yarovenko’s performance was acceptable as both actresses are in almost every scene and indeed they are what makes the film so beautiful and interesting to watch, besides the story.
As a mainstream arty film is complex with Medem’s magic realism leading the story this time with paintings that if you’re familiar with the paintings, the simple painting’s presence will (sort of) tell you what the story will be about and if not, narrative will tell. Then you have Cupid that needs no explanation. If this had been a man and a woman story I’ll be talking SO different about the story and would have made a better analysis of what the story is really about. I saw the story but since Medem chose to have two women, it totally became irrelevant to me as the lesbian interest story became not only more interesting but so resembling real life that overcame me. But will share that yes Medem’s magic realism could have made the story a dream and yes, the visual narrative has a lot to do with two symbols, maps (including the great take with the upside down map of Microsoft’s Bing – plus all the other-) and mirrors.
Still I was able to appreciate the movie beyond the story and the two protagonist pas-de-deux and one… no, two particular scenes blew my mind. The first is when the camera enters the room -at the beginning- and the second is when the camera exits the room –at the end-in the same fashion as the first but backwards. In general the best this movie has –as a movie- is framing, camera takes and camera moves. Still there are a few, perhaps too many for such a beautiful film, really bad framing's.
I was reading a few reviews as well as viewers comments and since I know that this film is a must-be-seen for those that enjoy the lesbian interest film I have to share with you all that this is not necessarily a ‘normal’ genre film. First please remember that is European and second absolutely is a Julio Medem’s film. The second comment may be explained better if you saw -or could see before watching this one- Medem’s Sex and Lucia, for example. I’m mentioning this as if you know Medem’s work I’m sure you will enjoy this film a lot more than just watching because is a lesbian interest movie.
I strongly recommend the film beyond the lesbian interest genre but please don’t expect steamy sex as the many trailers suggest and even if the two protagonists are nude almost the entire film (which is exactly how you are in real-life inside the closed doors of a hotel room) after about ten minutes you will forget that they’re nude.
Of course I LOVE the film as a lesbian interest film but also as a Julio Medem’s film.
Big Enjoy!!!
Watch trailer @MOC (well, if I find one that doesn’t exploit the sex scenes – it’s impossible so no trailer)
Storyteller - usually I agree with you, but in this case we clearly had very, very different experiences. :-) Though I'm glad you enjoyed the movie. I was really struck by how bored I was throughout. I felt it took a special touch to make the subject matter so uninteresting - though that "perfect strangers" song that they wouldn't stop playing didn't help either. Someone else at the screening I attended summarized it as "the Bataan Death March of lesbian sex films" - which was strong but similar to how I'd characterize the experience. ;-)
ReplyDeleteThese are my thoughts at the time I saw it. Later I learned it was a remake (which I suspected at the time but wasn't sure) of "In Bed" (from Argentina or Chile I think) which I saw several years ago and loved.
Anyway - really am glad if others enjoy it - that's what's important.
Rich, I'm glad that sometimes we agree but as you probably know it's more interesting when someone disagrees with you.
ReplyDeleteI can understand your point and also read some reviews where critics strongly complain about the music and how thin the plot is, so you're not alone in thinking that the movie was terrible, boring and not interesting. As a matter of fact the movie is described as a box office flop.
Think that Medem did a good portrait of women, as is a fact that women TALK a lot... maybe all the talking made the movie boring and not entertaining for many, obviously except for women! lol!
I believe that where the movie could make money is with dvd sales as definitively the natural target is a market niche that usually waits for the dvd so can watch at the comfort (and privacy) of their homes.
But I'm SO glad that even if it was unintentionally (was it?) Julio Medem did a specific genre film that will please many that enjoy watching this type of stories in film.
I really appreciate your comments and thank you very much for them, please keep them coming.
:-). I'd suggest if you havent seen it trying 'In bed' which is a very similar film but I felt without some of the flaw. My guess is that if you liked this version you'll also really enjoy In Bed.
ReplyDeleteWill try to watch it! :)
ReplyDeleteI accidentally came across your blog while searching information about "Habitacion en Roma" and I was so happy to read your review. You brought to light all the little things I liked about this movie, all Medem's magical touches and, of course, you noticed some little things that are not so good, but still, if you can watch beyond, they don't spoil the magic and the beauty of the movie.
ReplyDeleteIn Russia a lot of people didn't like it. And even some people that have seen Medem's movies couldn't watch it and reviewed it as a weak piece.
And I was so glad to see that somebody shares my opinion and sees what's so touching about it.
Thank you.
I adore Medem. I like the way he sees love, life, creation. He always inspires me by his magic, colours, by his wonderful stories, by his "coups de foudre" that make the heart beat faster.
And I adore Spanish cinema as you adore French)).
Thank you once more for being so intelligent and delicate.
Katya Shafran
Thank you Katya for your kind words. Be assured that there are many of us that enjoyed the film and many more will enjoy it when DVD becomes available around the world. It's a good Medem's film but must of all, is a very good genre film. :)
ReplyDelete